The Nintendo Switch 2 has finally been unveiled, but the excitement from its recent Direct showcase has been clouded by growing criticism. With leaks spoiling much of the surprise and new pricing details raising eyebrows, the Switch 2 is now being compared to the Xbox One — and not in a good way.
Pricing Woes and a Familiar Statement
One of the biggest controversies stems from the console’s steep pricing. Reports suggest that Mario Kart World, a flagship title, will cost $80 digitally and up to $90 physically. Combine that with a launch price higher than expected, and fans are understandably uneasy.
Fuel was added to the fire when Nintendo of America president Doug Bowser attempted to address these concerns in an interview with CBC. He stated:
“We recognize there are some people that may not be able to afford [the Switch 2’s] price point. That’s why we wanted to make the other Switch platforms available, so [people] still have an opportunity to come into our gaming universe… in whatever rung of the platform they come in.”
While the comment was likely intended to reassure players that the original Switch would still receive support, many gamers were reminded of Don Mattrick’s infamous Xbox One-era quote:
“Fortunately, we have a product for people who aren’t able to get some form of connectivity. It’s called Xbox 360.”
That tone-deaf messaging became symbolic of Xbox One’s rough start — and now, Nintendo risks walking down a similar path.
Hardware Features and Mixed Reactions
While not an online-only console like the early plans for Xbox One, the Nintendo Switch 2 does include features that draw comparisons to Microsoft’s missteps:
- Game sharing options that feel oddly familiar
- A built-in camera, raising questions about privacy and utility
- Game key cards that don’t actually contain full games, echoing concerns over digital ownership and DRM
Some fans have pushed back, pointing out that Nintendo has toyed with game sharing as far back as the 2004 Nintendo DS, which allowed multiplayer experiences with a single game cartridge. But even with that context, skepticism remains.
Tariffs and Economic Pressure
Beyond hardware and features, economic concerns and tariffs are further dampening enthusiasm. With inflation and Trump-era tariffs on electronics still in effect, some fear that the Switch 2’s price could rise even more before — or shortly after — launch.
Final Thoughts
It’s clear that while Nintendo has loyal fans, the Switch 2’s reveal has left many divided. For those unwilling or unable to upgrade, the current Switch lineup remains an option — for now. But unless Nintendo shifts its messaging and pricing strategy, it may find itself reliving the missteps of a competitor it once easily outpaced.
